About New Buffalo Insurance Agency

Risk is an intrinsic part of life, whether you’re kickstarting a dream business, growing a family, purchasing your dream home, or embarking on an epic journey. Life is unpredictable, but at New Buffalo Insurance Agency, we stand by you, ensuring protection through life’s unpredictability.

Life’s challenges can be unexpected, but insurance is your safeguard. With our broad range of policies, you can face these challenges with assurance. From safeguarding your home to ensuring your travels are protected, we’ve got you covered.

At the heart of it all is peace of mind. With insurance, you can immerse in life’s adventures, knowing we have your back. Let’s journey through life’s surprises together, prepared and confident.

When Protecting Your Life Matters We've Have You Covered

  • We are an independent agency

    What does this mean? It means we work for YOU not the insurance company. An independent agent is not tied to any specific insurance company. Instead, we work with multiple insurance carriers, giving us the flexibility to shop around and find the best coverage options for your specific needs. Think of us as your trusted advisor, guiding you through the complexities of home insurance.

  • We tailor your coverage to you

    When you approach an independent agent like us for home insurance, we will take the time to understand your unique circumstances, the value of your home, and the contents within it. We'll assess factors like the location of your property, its age, and any specific risks that may be associated with it.

  • We have options

    Once we have a clear understanding of your requirements, the independent agent will leverage their network of insurance providers to gather quotes from different companies. We'll compare coverage options, deductibles, and premiums to find the most suitable policies that align with your needs and budget.

  • We make it easy

    In the event of a claim or if you need to make changes to your policy, we will be there to assist you. We act as a liaison between you and the insurance company, ensuring a smooth and efficient process.


We help business owners control
their TOTAL cost of risk.

3 ways to start a conversation with New Buffalo Insurance:

  • Email Us

    Click to send us an email

  • Call Us

    Click to call us directly

  • Visit Us

    Click to get directions

Call Email Claims Payments