We'll Manage The Risk, So You Can Reap The Reward.

At New Buffalo Insurance, we help individuals, families, and business owners shop the insurance marketplace to find a combination of cost & coverage that meets your unique needs. We pride ourselves in making an often complicated process, much simpler, so you can have a clear picture of your risk profile. Start a conversation today but clicking the button below.

We're the Insurance Agent your business never knew it needed.

Welcome to New Buffalo Insurance Agency, where we break free from the insurance norm and embrace our independent spirit! We're not your average insurance agency - and here's why it's awesome to do business with us.

As an independent agency, we're not tied down to any one provider, we have many. That gives us the freedom to explore the different insurance markets available to us and help you find a match.

And when life throws you a curveball, we've got your back. Our customer service is top-notch, with lightning-fast responses and a dedication to making your insurance journey as smooth as possible. We're ready to assist you with claims and answer your questions.

So, why settle for the same old insurance routine? Join the independent insurance revolution at New Buffalo Insurance Agency. We're here to make insurance fun, personalized, and hassle-free. Let's break free from the ordinary and embark on an insurance adventure together!


Our process is simple:

  • Start Online

    Provide initial info.

  • We Shop Based On Your Needs

    We explore options for you.

  • Choose Your Plan

    Pick your preferred coverage.


We have a plan for you

At New Buffalo Insurance, our focus is personalized insurance strategies. Our skilled advisors formulate plans addressing your property, liability, and worker compensation risks. We extend beyond basic coverage, collaborating with you to understand your business, identify risks, and suggest proactive actions. We're here to answer your questions and help navigate the complicated industry.


We are here for you

At New Buffalo Insurance, partnership is at our core. We help our clients by offering insurance coverage recommendations specific to your business. Beyond policy creation, we support you through implementation, claims processing, and adjustments. Our team simplifies complex insurance matters and helps in handling your risks efficiently. We answer your inquiries and concerns with empathy, striving for ease, understanding, and open dialogue. Regardless of challenges, our commitment remains firm - standing with you at each turn, promoting sustainable growth and resilience.

Commercial Insurance

We insure hundreds of businesses of all shapes and sizes. 

Risk Management

We get you the right coverage for the right price.

Home & Auto Insurance

Let us create a custom Home and Auto package for you.

YouTube video
YouTube video
YouTube video
YouTube video

We help business owners control
their TOTAL cost of risk.

3 ways to start a conversation with New Buffalo Insurance:

  • Email Us

    Click to send us an email

  • Call Us

    Click to call us directly

  • Visit Us

    Click to get directions

Call Email About Payments